Baton down the hatches
In my thirty-odd years of orchestral experience, I’ve encountered all flavors on the podium. I’ve seen micromanagers, and the ones who just want to go home early. I’ve seen great technicians who have nothing to say, and artists with a lot to say who don’t know how to say it. The “ahead-of-the-beat” phenomenon isn’t necessarily my first complaint, but I do recognize that it’s an issue worth exploring.
I would estimate that 80-90% of the conductors I see (as in, right in front of me, on the podium) are “ahead-of-the-beat” conductors. I don’t know where this tradition started, but I’m happy to join any chorus of players who would prefer to see an ictus in real time. On the rare occasions when I meet a conductor who wants to be on top of the beat, s/he always has to tell the orchestra, “No, you’re behind me — the beat is here, and I want the sound to coincide.” The first iteration is useless, of course, but the second generally produces an orchestra that responds very quickly and precisely.
I have never understood the “behind-the-beat” phenomenon, and would submit that if more conductors would insist on accurate rhythmic precision, then we’d all be playing better performances.
No comments yet.
Add your comment