Auditioning the Audition Process
Robert’s report of the rarity of un-granted tenure jives with my experience, too. A few thoughts….
1. Perhaps this confirms that for all its flaws, maybe the current system in the US works pretty well.
2. It may also reflect the fact that the talent pool is so deep and so accomplished that to paraphrase an pol from many years ago, “there ain’t a dime’s worth of difference” between one audition winner and another. We may just be hiring the person who happens to have their skill, nerve, stamina, biorhythms, and luck all line up on one particular day. And there may, indeed, be other candidates who had one little star just a bit out of alignment who would have been just as good (or maybe even better) than the winner. But if that winner proves good enough at the day-in-day-out job to win tenure, then who’s to say the audition yielded anything but the (or a) right result?
3. We don’t make music with droids. We make music with human beings, who are, of course, human. And so are we. So unless someone REALLY doesn’t fit in (or unless their stars aligned in a totally anomalous way on audition day), it’s likely that by the time we’ve shared however long the probation period is, very few probationers have risen (or sunk) to the level where we just can’t bear to live with them.
Having had the chance to read Nathan’s most recent post, a brief reply regarding “politics”. While I’m sure there are some deserving musicians who’ve been denied tenure because they didn’t kow-tow sufficiently, I suspect that “politics” is more often than not a fig-leaf for the person who feels wronged.
I’ve heard rumblings that “politics” is the reason that many of my orchestra’s string openings are won by members of the orchestra auditioning to move up in the section. But we almost never drop our audition screen, and especially not when there’s a chance that a candidate could be “one of ours.” If insiders are winning, they’re winning fair and square.
We were once accused of “politics” at a harp audition — someone was SURE that a local harpist had fixed the audition, and the “proof” was in the audition list. The list did, indeed, have “harpist” written all over it, but that’s because I had vetted the list with the Milwaukee Symphony’s fabulous Danis Kelley — who wasn’t a candidate. And no, the local harpist didn’t win the audition!
No comments yet.
Add your comment